A Preliminary Study of Perception and Coping Mechanism of Breast Cancer Patients in An Iranian City
Ali A. Moqaddas1, Fatemeh Adjdari2, Akbar Aghajanian3*
1Shiraz University, Shiraz Iran
2Shiraz University, Shiraz, Iran
3Department of Sociology, Fayetteville State University, Fayetteville, NC 28301
*Corresponding author: Dr. Akbar Aghajanian, Department of Sociology, Fayetteville State University, Fayetteville, NC 28301,
Submitted: 05-04-2016 Accepted: 06-06-2016 Published: 11-29-2016
coping with the disease and the aftermath of the technology based treatments. Except for a few educated women, the majority of the subjects studied in this research saw their situation as catastrophic and ambiguous. They relied on their religious belief and family support to cope with their situation, but had limited success due to their lack of knowledge about the natural order of the disease and consequences of treatment. While there is need for more comprehensive studies of coping strategies using representative sample of breast cancer patients across rural and urban areas of Iran, the findings from the present study calls for organized and systematic community based support system to help women faced with this disease, to cope.
Breast cancer is the most frequently occurring form of cancer worldwide among women, and the second highest cause of cancer deaths. In Iran research on biomedical and social behavioral aspects of breast cancer accelerated during the 1990s. The support of government for establishment of regional and provincial registries helped with improvement of the availability of data for measuring the trends and variation in the incidence and mortality rates of breast cancer . These epidemiological studies have shown that breast cancer hits at younger ages than conventionally seen in other countries; the incidence rates is increasing; and in most cases when diagnosed, the cancer is in stages two and higher. The crude annual incidence rate of breast cancer is estimated at 120 per 100,000 women. It is estimated that under conservative assumptions, the number of new cases of breast cancer in Iran will be more than 15,000 in 2030 [2, 3]. A number of studies based on regional registries have shown that the average age of breast cancer in Iran is about 10 years younger than the average age of breast cancer in Western countries . While there has been some research published on biomedical risk factors of breast cancer in Iran, social and behavioral aspect of breast cancer and its consequences has been less studied [5,6]. A few studies have focused on quality of life and coping of breast cancer patients [7, 8].There is serious need for expansion of such studies based on the Iranian cultural-social environment.
A major factor in the coping strategy and success is the perception of the patients in relation to the situation that has emerged for them. This issue is very important in the context of the situation of the Iranian women who not only are the victim of breast cancer at young ages, but have limited knowledge of the risk of breast cancer and the prevention strategies. Research on understanding the perception of breast cancer and how this perception is related to the copying strategies of the Iranian patients is very limited. The present preliminary study focuses on filling the gap in this literature.
Drawing on ground theory, this study utilized qualitative data collected from 23 female breast cancer patients. The target population for the study was breast cancer patients at different stage of treatment visiting oncology specialists in private or public outpatient clinics or outpatient clinic in hospitals in the city of Shiraz in southern Iran. The city of Shiraz has a population of more than a million and since 1960s has grown to become a major center for health and medical education services in the southern region. Patients from rural and urban areas in the region come to Shiraz to access high level treatment
for cancer and other degenerative diseases in several large medical centers and many outpatient specialty offices. The study protocol was approved by the Research Committee of College of Social Sciences at Shiraz University. For the purpose of recruitment, trained university senior students visited the collaborative oncology establishments and introduced themselves to the breast cancer patients. The students explained the purpose of the study to the patients and the persons who accompanied them and invited the patient to join the study. The interviewers made sure to clarify that the study does not have anything to do with the treatment they are receiving at the establishment. If the patient agreed to join the study, an appointment was setup for the in-depth interview.
The volunteering patients were given the choice of interview at their home or in a private corner in the oncology establishment.
At the time of interview they were reminded again that their participation is voluntary and they may stop at any time during the interview. The interviews took on the average about one and half hours. In a few cases a second visit was needed to continue the interview. During the interviews some patients were very nervous. Some expressed themselves with cry and some were happy. Among those visited at home, some were very neat and some had very sloppy home environment.
Characteristics of the Sample
Out of the 26 recruited patients, 23 completed the interviews and provided data for the study. The average age of the participating patients was 48.6 and out of the 23 patients, six were 40 years and younger. Almost half of the subjects were diagnosed within the last two years. The majority of them were married. The average education for the subjects was nine years and only three were illiterate. Ten out of 23 had some paid employment status, who were either retired or they were currently not working due to their treatment. Both education and work status data suggested that our sample has a higher level of education and work participation compared to the general population of middle age and older women in Shiraz. Five of the subjects were from out of Shiraz and they came to Shiraz to access care that did not exist in their home town.
Perception of the Event
Out of the 23 patients 15 had total mastectomy, five had Lumpectomy, and the rest were under chemotherapy. Hence all subjects had some pain, deformation, inflammation or itching and other physical impact of the breast cancer and they were faced with some painful event that they perceived differently. The event seemed to have higher density for subjects who were exasperated by other circumstances such as economic issues particularly related to the cost of treatment. Another exasperating factor was marginality due to being in a different and a large town for those patients who came from rural and small towns to Shiraz.
For those subjects that mentioned they have had relatives with breast cancer, the situation was more aggravating if their relatives had low survival and harsh experience. On the other hand, they saw their situation more hopeful, if their relatives had survived long after diagnosis. The subjects who were divorced, separated or single had a more aggravating perception as compared to those with nuclear and extended family network and support. The cancer event was less aggravating for those subjects with more knowledge of cancer development as compared to those with less solid knowledge about cancer. Three situational perspectives emerged from the axial coding of the interviews. These were: catastrophe, uncertainty, and natural. The catastrophic perspective viewed cancer and its related pains as a “difficult situation or revenge” in response to bad behavior. Cancer is also seen a catastrophe due to “God’s will” for testing the followers. For example, Giti, a 62 year old subject with total mastectomy says, “we have engaged in bad ills..it is important to die when all the sins are forgiven by God”. Parvin, 56 years old subject perceived her situation like this, “I think perhaps God wanted me to slow down in work ….. God gave me this pain to understand myself better”.
The subjects with uncertain perspective expressed wonder as why they got into this situation; they do not see any explanation. Sara a 59 year old subject has a child who is institutionalized due to mental limitations. She also has modest economic circumstances. She expressed her uncertainty of the cancer event like this, “I had enough difficulties, so I did not think I will be also struck by cancer”. Fati, a 45 year old patient who was divorced at a very early age, expressed her uncertainty of her situation by focusing on fate. “When I learned that I had cancer, I got stressed and cried… I thought I am faced with a bad fate”. Shamsi, 65 year old widow, says, “Nobody in my family had cancer and I did not think that this disease catch me”. Leylla, 54 years old and divorced showed her uncertainty by evil eyes. “I have had some continuous bad events. I believe I have been affected by evil eyes”.
The natural perspective is linked to knowledge of cancer and cancer development with regard to life-style issues and heredity and other scientific explanation. Sanaz, a 48 years old subject expressed this perspective by saying, “Cancer is like other diseases that demand treatment; the treatment has improved; facilities are more available now; the probability of cure and survival has improved”. Nikoo, a 39 years old subject expresses her natural explanation by saying, “I realize that in every second many of the cells change”. Nikoo has college education and has been working as a teacher. Educational level and professional working status are associated with perception of breast cancer as something that can happen to all women.
The coding revealed three coping approaches. These were religious and faith, family, and medical instrumentation. The religious coping was based on strong faith in God and what God’s wishes were. Miracles and serendipity were considered very important. One’s death was considered as another life and the expectation of better things after the life in this world. The family orientation coping focused on how family members particularly husbands and sons can be helpful and supportive in these situations. The medical instrumentation coping centered in the support from experts and specialists in the field and finding more experienced well-known physicians for more advanced technology for treatment.
Classification of Perspectives and Coping Approaches
The intersection of perspectives and copying approaches found from the 23 patients expressions are presented by cross-tabulation in Table 1. Due to low cell frequencies in the Table, it is not possible to calculate any statistical index and our interpretations are descriptive. The subjects who felt their condition was catastrophic relayed on religion and rituals for coping. These subjects showed very high level of coping. The women who perceived their situation as insecure focused on family relationship to cope with their problems. The subjects who considered disease a natural part of life and events that can happen to anyone, utilized instrumentation, technology and scientific progress in their coping mechanism and expressions. The lowest coping level was observed among women with catastrophic perspective who appealed to their familial relationships.
The second most adjusted group of the subjects included those who had insecure perception and depended on religion for coping. For these women religion and religious practices were frequently reported as a relief from the anxiety of the consequences of the disease. The highest copying level belonged to the subjects who were familiar with breast cancer as a disease among women all around the world and knew technology and pharmaceutical solutions are available to help. These women supplemented their instrumental coping with support from family and relaying on faith. They showed a high level of confidence in treatment and technology that can lead to their improvement. On the other hand, the patients with insecure perception saw themselves in a structured situation that cannot and will not change.
Table 1. Cross-tabulation of perspectives and mode of coping among women with breast cancer.
Summary and Conclusion
The life expectancy of women in Iran has increased in the last quarter of the 20th century (Abbasi-Shavazi, et al, 2005). On the other hand the incidence of degenerative diseases including breast cancer has increased. These trends are contemporary with a growing incidence of breast cancer among women in urban areas. Hence, a growing section of tertiary medicine has emerged for treatment through surgery, chemotherapy and radiation therapy. Both the disease and the treatment technology are new to Iranian women particularly those coming from rural villages and small towns to get treatment in large cities. Many of them are unaware of the trajectory of the disease and the side effects of the treatment. Yet, despite the growth in technology, very limited support exist for culturally relevant information dissemination and coping support for women getting various treatments. The majority of our subjects reported catastrophic and insecure situation about their disease and perceived it as penalty for what they have done wrong and they kept asking what they have done wrong to deserve this. Given the role of religious and family institutions in Iran, it is not surprising that the great majority of the women depended on religion and family in their coping effort. However, their lack of knowledge about the natural origin of the disease, the treatment technology, and its side effects, disturbed their coping process.
The data we presented here is limited in representation of the breast cancer population and the variables measuring a variety of socio-demographic, disease history, treatment side effects, and coping mechanisms. However, it is obvious that there is need for developing community based support system which utilizes the religious beliefs and practices and family resources to strengthen the coping effort of the growing number of women who are faced with this disease.
1. Abbasi-Shavazi J.M , Hoseini-Chavochi M. Trends and emerging issues of health and mortality in the Islamic Republic of Iran. Asian Population Studies. 2005, 163: 147-160.
4.Ahmadian M., Ma’rof Redzuan, Emby Z, Asnarulkhadi A. S. Women’s community participation levels in community-based health programs regarding breast cancer prevention in metropolitan Tehran, Iran. Asian Social Science, 2010.
Cite this article: Akbar Aghajanian. A Preliminary Study of Perception and Coping Mechanism of Breast Cancer Patients in An Iranian City. J J Epidemiol Prevent. 2016, 2(3): 032.